My Engagement Ring Is Too Small: Now What?

First things first—don’t panic.

We understand how that might not be the easiest thing to do at the moment—especially if all of this is happening at once and you’re totally overcome with excitement. And why wouldn’t you be excited, right? You’ve got a fantastic partner, and likely just had an epic proposal.

And now, you have an insanely beautiful ring that’s begging to slide onto your finger with ease—but instead, you’re staring down at an amazing engagement ring that’s just too small, that you can’t display, and that’s left you feeling just a little bit heartbroken.

Of course, it’s easy to freak out a little.

But, we’ve got good news. For as upsetting as it might be now, it’s a totally fixable solution. Even better, that first round of good news we just shared probably means that your spouse-to-be is probably off-the-hook and out of the doghouse for getting your ring size wrong (we joke, of course).

Check out our helpful guide that dives into the basics of ring resizing, how to tell if your ring is too small and useful next steps for taking care of a tight engagement ring.

Popular diamond shapes

What Exactly Do I Do If My Ring Is Too Small?

If you’re sure that your ring is too small (we’ll get into common signs later in this article), then you’re going to need to get your ring resized.

While that might sound scary, we can assure you, it’s a very common, everyday practice, and there are thousands upon thousands of jewelers who can happily tackle the task for you.

A quick note—we definitely recommend taking your ring to an expert to be resized. While there are other maintenance tasks you can likely take care of on your own when it comes to engagement rings, resizing is another ball game. Though it’s a common job for jewelers, it’s also a bit of a complicated one that requires training, practice, and experience.

Let’s Talk Resizing: Facts, Fiction, and Everything in Between

Resizing, in theory, seems pretty simple, right? Just based on its name you can guess what the process means—they’re stretching your ring to ensure the perfect fit.

There are a few tried and true methods for resizing a small wedding ring. One strategy involves a jeweler cutting the ring’s shank and adding a bridge to increase the size of the band—during this process, the jeweler will pull apart the two sides of the ring then add the metal by soldering.

Another strategy for resizing a ring that’s too small is to stretch the shank by pulling it apart and elongating it. This strategy is complex and, without a professional behind the helm, you run the risk of damaging your engagement ring. Of course, an experienced jeweler can manage this without an issue and can certainly provide you with a properly sized ring.

Unfortunately, because ring resizing is an exceptionally tricky process, there’s a lot of misinformation out there about how it’s done, how it works, and whether or not it’s a viable fix for a ring that’s too tight.

Popular diamond shapes

Keep on reading as we break down some ring resizing facts and myths.

    Does Resizing a Ring Weaken It?
    Technically, this is true to an extent. But, it’s not as substantial as many people might think. Of course, when you stretch or cut a ring, the slightest mistake can cause damage. That being said, if your jeweler has resized your ring properly, the risk of actually breaking your ring is incredibly minimal.

    How Many Times Can You Resize a Ring?
    A ring can be resized as many as 2-4 times and can be resized up to 2-5 sizes, based on the delicacy and structure of the ring itself. Of course, every time you resize a ring, you do weaken it ever so slightly, so we recommend being cautious with how often (and how much bigger), you’re planning to resize it.

    How Easy Is It to Resize a Ring?
    If you’re working with an experienced jeweler, then he or she is likely resizing rings daily, so stretching or cutting your too-small engagement ring will be a breeze. Further, while every jeweler shop will vary in price, there are plenty of places that offer this service for a minimal fee. There are even jewelry stores that include a free resizing within a few months of purchasing the ring. When you purchase your engagement ring from 12FIFTEEN Diamonds, your ring comes with a Manufacturer Defect Guarantee. This means for the lifetime of your ring (if there is a manufacturing defect), we will repair or replace your ring free of charge.

    How Long Does It Take to Resize a Ring?
    It all depends on the professional you choose to work with. Resizing shouldn’t take more than one-to-two weeks, but some shops can be very booked out. Regardless, the actual process of resizing doesn’t take all that long—it simply depends on how busy your jeweler is.

Popular diamond shapes

How Can I Really Tell If My Ring is Too Small?

For some, a too-small ring is pretty obvious—it simply won’t fit on your finger. But for others, an ill-fitting, size-too-small ring might not be so blatant.

Even further, because your hands and fingers often fluctuate in size, a once well-fitting engagement ring might end up being too small or too tight one day, which, if left unchecked, could potentially cause some serious health and circulation concerns.

That’s why it’s super important to be able to pin down the signs of a ring that’s too tiny. Here are a few quick checks to run through with your engagement ring to make sure it’s properly fitted. If you’re experiencing any of these ring fit symptoms, you’re likely in need of a ring resize.

    The Ring Won’t Come Off
    This is the first sign that something is probably wrong with your ring size. If your ring flat-out just isn’t budging off your finger, you’re more than likely dealing with a ring that doesn’t fit.

    Ring Muffin Top
    If you see a little pudge of skin folding over the top of your ring (a phenomenon we so lovingly refer to as ring muffin top), your ring is probably too snug.

    You Can’t Turn Your Ring
    You should be able to comfortably rotate your ring around your finger both clockwise and counterclockwise. If this simply isn’t happening for you, you’re likely dealing with a ring that’s too small.

    Pale Fingers
    If you look down one day and notice that your ring finger is a slightly different color than your other fingers, we suggest you remove your engagement ring as quickly as possible and take it in to get resized.

    Serious Ring Pain
    If your ring finger flat out hurts, there’s likely something wrong with the fit of your ring. Our rule of thumb (no pun intended) is that if your ring finger is catching your attention because of how it physically feels, something is probably off.

    No, we’re not talking about those love-sick tingles and butterflies that your partner gives you, we’re talking about a tingling in your ring finger. This is another sure sign that your engagement ring is probably too tight and you may need to get it resized.

Popular diamond shapes

Now that you know how to determine if your ring is too small and what to do if it is, you can fix it properly. It’s important not to rush into a resizing unless you’re 100% sure your ring is too small. Since your finger size can fluctuate throughout the day due to the temperature and the amount of salt you eat, you should wait at least a few days to make a definitive decision. Once you know, contact your trusted jeweler to get it fitting just right.

Win a Pair of Earrings!

Enter our monthly contest for your chance to win a pair of lab grown diamond earrings.

No thanks
Thank You!

You are now entered to win a pair of lab grown diamond earrings. Make sure you watch your email for more information and to find out if you’re the lucky winner.